Start with apology
smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon
We have rarely seen confessions and apologies from political leaders for their wrongdoings. Gagan Thapa’s prompt response from him on the allegation against him is very significant in the context of the political deadlock the country has experienced at the moment.

By Jeevan Baniya

 
An apology might be taken as an act or weakness of a coward person. But it also demands a lot of courage and sincerity; thus very few can apologize.

I happened to read this news piece, which is often not good news anymore and is rather lightly understood in Nepal. The congress party lawmaker, Gagan Thapa realized his carelessness and publicly apologized for not providing information of his personal properties within the deadline to the office of constitutional committee.  He further expressed his commitment to publicize each and every part of his life so that people will be able to read as an open book. We have rarely seen confessions and apologies from political leaders for their wrongdoings. Gagan Thapa’s prompt response from him on the allegation against him is very significant in the context of the political deadlock the country has experienced at the moment. I should come to this point later.

The problem that started from the Maoists’ decision to sack then chief of the Nepal army, Rookmangud Katawal without making broad consensus in the cabinet they led. There remain no doubts that their one-sided decision was ill-intended even though it was a constitutional decision (so far I understand from the interim constitution of Nepal). The Maoist intention behind the hasty decision can be well understood from party chairman Pushpa Kamal Dahal’s Saktikhor videotape.

Subsequently, the president made the unconstitutional move after he was motivated by the leaders of other political parties, although, we can not be sure whether the president was very much concerned about the legality of his decision to reinstate the sacked army chief in the middle of the night. The move has been interpreted by many legal pundits in many different ways; and the Supreme Court of Nepal remains almost dead to address this issue--thus nothing can be expected from it. This led to the resignation of the then Prime Minister Dahal and Maoists demand for ‘civilian supremacy’. Now they have even launched second-phase protest programmes for ‘restoring civilian supremacy’, which has generated huge frustration among the citizens in Nepal.

To further anger the Maoists and complicate the peace process, defense minister Bidhya Bhandari in recent days has been making irresponsible statements regarding the need for review on the peace accord and possible deployment of Nepal army to crush the Maoist protest. For Prime Minister Nepal and UML leadership, her statements remain to be her personal as if she is outside of the government and the party. Similarly, the Maoists’ commitment to counter the possible suppression and their thuggery seen in the different parts of the country in recent days -- all point to more chaotic situation in the coming up days.

Despite the fact that attempts made to address the Maoists’ demand in the past by the leaders of major political parties, the political developments demand a broad consensus at the earliest; otherwise the country is very likely to plunge deep into conflict.

It is very clear that the stigma of the quest for power on the part of some leaders has created an unfavourable environment in the country. For me, the expectation of resolving of the problem through any decision of the present coalition government is just a wishful thinking. The keys to unlock the present deadlock are in the hands of main leaders of major political parties and the President.

Much ink has been spilled to stipulate the growing need for pragmatic thinking among leaders for taking decisions to drive the country to the right direction, but unfortunately, such possibility is withering away. If they look at the commitments they made to people, leaders must forge a consensus. But, who cares?

Let me now get back to Gagan Thapa’s apology episode. One sees a way to resolving the present political crisis based on this episode. In my eyes, Thapa can be a great lesson and the point of departure to resolve the present deadlock. How?

Yes, the answer is very straight forward. Apologize!!

First, Prachanda should apologize for his ill-intended decision to sack the then army chief. Then, President Yadav should apologize for his unconstitutional move. And, minister Bhandari must apologize for her attempts to further complicate the peace process. The first two apologies can be very crucial in the meantime. Yet, it demands bold courage like that from Gagan Thapa. The history will appreciate your apology and the people of Nepal will solute your act.

Please do it for the country desperately needs it from you at this critical juncture. You can do it for the good of Nepali people and the country.

(Baniya is a PhD candidate at the University of Oslo, Norway. He can be reached at: baniyajeevan@hotmail.comThis e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it  )

 


Readers are kindly requested to avoid using offensive language and also refrain from issuing threats to others.
+/-
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
+/- View Comments
Search
As postings are shown online immediately, please be warned of offensive comments
markolee   |147.91.1.xxx |2009-11-07 08:11:11
After explanation from Jeevan ji, it is now apparent that the article is not
about to highlight any bad role model. But, it is about apology either it comes
from good/bad people, it is nevertheless appreciable.
Keep writing...
Arun  - To Jeevan Dai.   |203.32.178.xxx |2009-11-07 04:06:43
My intention was not to insult Jeeven Dai but to vent my frustrations for a very
bad leader who is climbing his ladder of success all for wrong reasons. I am a
Gen Y and I think we deserve a better leader for our future. It just happened to
be wrong choice of example for 'Start with Apology' article. I truly respect
Jeevan Dai's idea and yes you've written it all for good reasons. Thank you.
Jeevan  - Again.......   |129.240.164.xxx |2009-11-06 08:38:15
I respect your comments even though your comments are based on
surfacial
understanding of the theme of my article. The article is not to
praise Gagan
Thapa as such; rather it is to highlight the need of confession of
the past
wrongdoings from the leaders that gave birth of the present state
of
deadlock.

@ The Anonymous friend, what do you think are the
criterions
for becoming a matured person? It seems to me that you have
stipulated your
comments by uming that I am young (you must have based your
comments by just looking at the photo that the article contains). what if I put
a photo in which I look much older; may be I would look matured.
I suggest you
to first
seriously make comments on the substance of the article, rather than
to be preoccupied with some fairy umptions.

And as an educated person, I
expect
you to get engaged in intellectual debate; for that, you can consider
the manner that you (arun a...
Jeevan baniya  - Reply to Anonymous and Arun   |129.240.164.xxx |2009-11-06 08:34:09
I respect your comments even though your comments are based on surfacial
understanding of the theme of my article. The article is not to praise Gagan
Thapa as such; rather it is to highlight the need of confession of the past
wrongdoings from the leaders that gave birth of the present state of
deadlock.

@ The Anonymous friend, what do you think are the criterions
for becoming a matured person? Is seems to me that you have stipulated your
comments by uming that I am young (you must have based your comments by just
looking at the photo that the article contains). what if I put a photo in which
I look much older; may be I would look matured.
I suggest you to first
seriously make comments on the substance of the article, rather than to be
preoccupied with some fairy umptions.

And as an educated person, I expect
you to get engaged in intellectual debate; for that, you can consider the manner
that you (arun as well)...
Nami Shrestha Palikhe   |222.251.198.xxx |2009-11-06 08:12:53
Good work!
Balbahadur  - This is the most boring article   |147.91.1.xxx |2009-11-05 22:27:13
Thanks to writer for providing ill research article, and praising the villian as
a hero.. I suppose the writer need to be neutral but should not adore any
villian in the public. You know very well who is the villian in Nepali youth
politics.
Anonymous  - A friend who wishes you well!   |80.10.46.xxx |2009-11-05 06:20:44
The first person who needs apolizing is yourself because with your pea-brain you
can hardly see into the depth of the issue.
First get matured; you're not fit
for the PhD.
To be a political pundit is not a matter of joke. Ask Mr. Dhruba
Adhikary!
Arun  - A villion becomes a hero over night here.   |220.239.232.xxx |2009-11-04 00:11:08
I appreciate the fact that an extremely opportunist Gagan finally apoloziged to
Nepali People and managed to attract some fools like Jeevan Baniya but I doubt
there is any honesty in his action. I know Gagan and his ill intentions very
well. He may be a new face of NC but eqally as bad as his predecessors - please
be adviced. I know him in person. He is no better there the rest of these
bastards.
Devendra Pant (USA)  - Learn to self-govern   |134.129.165.xxx |2009-11-03 13:36:55
Why should Nepali people suffer from the follies of incompetent and outdated
leaders? "New" Nepal needs young leaders with new vision and strategic
thinking. Enough of slave mentality and "bhardari prabritti"!! People
are looking for strategic direction and not for personal "apology".
History will not pardon those who lack the ability to govern themselves.
Ashok Baniya  - Very insightful article   |202.70.82.xxx |2009-11-03 07:45:45
There is indeed a need of broad concensus among the larger players of the
country. Intrinsic responsibilities from them is imperative,and every citizens
are demanding it with confessing their past mistakes with the Nepalese people.
We are open hearted and will surely give them Pardon.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."